CB 1000

26 March 2015
In an Atmosphere of Fear, “Silence is Health”
by Jayson McNamara
Silence is Health
Jayson McNamara
Jayson is an Australian freelance journalist and writer based in Buenos Aires. His works have been published in Ámbito Financiero, the Buenos Aires Herald and a number of online media. Jayson is a permanent fixer in Buenos Aires for CNN and has reported for broadcast media in both Australia and New Zealand.

For someone who was born years later and thousands of kilometres away, the story of 1970s Argentina is simply unfathomable. Because from an early age we’re told that the mistakes of the past aren’t meant to repeat themselves. And yet Argentina from 1976 to 1983 mirrors Nazi Germany, for instance, in so many frightening ways.

Up to 30,000 people were murdered during the last of Argentina’s six dictatorships in the 20th century. Most of these people were never seen again, their bodies buried, burned or disposed of during the so-called “death flights” that the Navy carried out across the Atlantic Ocean.

General Jorge Rafael Videla’s regime almost got away with it, according to former editor of the The Buenos Aires Herald, Robert Cox. The local press said nothing and an atmosphere of fear ruled society with an iron first. “Silence is health,” the generals would say. “They made one big mistake,” says Cox. “And that was to think that the relatives of these people were willing to accept that their loved-ones wouldn’t be coming home.”

The Herald had long been an outsider in the local media game, which is perhaps why it came as a surprise to the military that this small English-language daily refused to toe the line with self-censorship.


Jayson is currently running a Crowdfunding campaign to fund Messenger On A White Horse. For more information on how you can help, please click here.

Under Cox’s leadership, the paper’s newsroom was opened up to the relatives of the so-called “disappeared” who flocked to the Herald each day in their dozens. On the side, Cox and his team would churn out carefully-worded editorials that called on the military to return the country to rule of law and to respond to pleas for information from distraught relatives across the country.

Some of them, like the Mothers and Grandmothers of Plaza de Mayo, have come a long way since then, and the support of the tiny English-language paper hasn’t been forgotten.
“He put breath into our struggle. He gave us everything he possibly could,” says the president of the Mothers of Plaza de Mayo – Founding Line, Marta Vásquez.

Those were trying times but Cox’s answer was hardly ever “no.” Supported by his wife, Maud, and helped down a very dangerous path by some of his colleagues, his work stands out for more reasons than one.

From beheadings to surveillance, journalists remain the target of people in positions of power. This suggests that words have the potential to change realities, to rattle those very people in power.

Journalism remains worthy and in need of protection. And despite time and distance, stories like the Herald’s remind us of our obligation to avoid the mistakes of the past.


‘It can be so sweet it makes you sick’ – Saint Sebastien France de Griessen – Album review

France’s vocals are intent, holistic and purposeful. The lyrics are as they need to be, at times urgent, also reflective, on time or in the moment.  The writing is mature and scripted and leaves openings for improvisation. The old school...

by Craig Bradbrook

‘It can be so sweet it makes you sick’ –...

France’s vocals are intent, holistic and purposeful. The lyrics are as they need to be, at times ...

by Craig Bradbrook

‘And I don’t, and I don’t, and I don’t…Ghost Stories...

[dropcap size=big]A[/dropcap]ny expectations that this new Coldplay album would be a return to fo...

by Craig Bradbrook

‘Coloured Into a Colour Never Seen’ Warpaints Warpaint – Review

The space and time Warpaint create lends this group to a unique continuum.  There is patience and...

by Craig Bradbrook

‘He always keeps his mouth shut…’ Cash Savage and the...

Cash Savage will tell a story with believable angst and paint a suitable background with violins,...

by Craig Bradbrook

‘Never want to wake up’ I Killed the Prom Queen...

I Killed the Prom Queen compositions are a diverse cross section of metal and mathcore genres tha...

by Craig Bradbrook